Jump to content

Heavy weather cruising


Recommended Posts

I was asked for this in another thread. Flame away.

 

 

 

First this is about cruising, racing is a whole nuther story. And since the majority of long distance cruisers are either couples or short handed that’s what I’ll focus on.

So a few generalised thoughts about cruising in the strong stuff:

Do not be in a hurry. It is often said the most dangerous thing on a boat is a calendar and it is true.

Learn to navigate. The overwhelming majority of boats lost are lost through human error and the vast majority of them through nav error. It is actually quite rare for a boat to be overwhelmed by wind and wave

Which brings up another point: the wind will not hurt you, the waves will. A good example is one of the best days sailing I’ve had was in the Gulf of Tehuantepec. The predominant wind is off the beach at 50kn. For days on end. After a few days waiting I got bored and we left anyway. Storm jib and a deep reef, Solid 45kn plus but 100m off the beach on a beam reach that slowly went aft. Great sail in flat water at full speed.

But the waves normally are associated with the wind so we talk about heavy weather rather than big wave sailing.

Here’s another idle thought. I often hear harbour racers claim they “haven’t reefed in 20 years”. Well at sea you will reef sooner than around the coast because of the sea conditions so if you haven’t reefed in years get out there and start practicing.

The whole point of your tactics should be to preserve the crew in the best condition you can at all times. That will often mean slowing down. There’s nothing wrong with heaving to to do the dishes or cook a meal. At sea you only have the resources contained by your toerail and the most critical are the crew. Take all the time you need to sleep, make sure you poop in the first 24 hrs, eat if you are hungry, never become dehydrated. If you are vulnerable take steps before you leave to deal with seasickness.

So let’s define what we are talking about.

Up to 28 kn winds – normal sailing.

28 – 38kn wind – heavy weather, but easily handled by any well equipped offshore cruiser. You’ll probably have stopped sailing and be sitting it out.

38 – 50kn , this is getting serious and as well as sitting it out you are thinking of special techniques to orient your boat to the waves.

At around 60 kn you are in survival mode and anything over 70 kn is scary as hell and there’s a chance you won’t come home, but taking the right steps earlier will improve your chances.

 

Downwind the tactics are easy. Drop sail if you are going too fast. Start at the back of the boat, i.e. drop the mizzen, then the main, then the jib. There have been three well reported deaths lately from mainsheets crossing the cockpit. Get the main down early. When you get to bare poles kick the drogue over – more on that later.

Upwind your tactics will be different to downwind. Somewhere around 30kn I stop sailing upwind and heave to. If you haven’t tried this before you will be astounded. I have gone from being beaten bloody at 6kn to thinking I was at the marina when down below. If you get nothing else from this essay, go out and practice heaving to (you can practice in under 30 kn, just use a bit more sail). When hove to have some food and a hot drink and get into your bunk where you can read or sleep. (your bunk will have a secure comfortable lee cloth right?) Stick your head out occasionally to make sure conditions haven’t worsened or that a ship isn’t going to run you down. The worst storm I have been in we were all below and totally unaware that a front had gone through with a 90 deg windshift and a LOT more wind till we woke up on the ceiling.

How do you heave to? The classic was to back the jib against the main. I believe that with nearly all modern boats this won’t work. Old boats had full keels and full forefoots (forefeet?). With a fin feel and a sloop rig the force on the jib will push the bow down until you are fore reaching (bad) or beam on to the seas (very bad). With a modern rig and a cutaway forefoot you can simply drop  the headsail (roll it up if that’s what you have), then pull the traveller to windward and sheet the main in hard. The main will push the bow to weather, but the boat shouldn’t have enough way on to tack , if it does then shorten the main. Lash the helm to leeward (Whatever happened to tiller combs?? I’ll look for a photo, they are cool). The goal is to come to a stop with the apparent wind about 40 -60 off the bow. You’ll probably be slipping sideways at ½ to 1kn, that’s perfect, but you want zero boatspeed.

As I said – learn this. Practice. Next time you are out on the gulf roll up the jib, strap the main in, lash the helm and go have a cup of tea. I can’t emphasize this enough.

As the wind increase and the boat tries to fore reach keep shortening the sail area. Eventually you will have just the trysail strapped to the weather quarter. This should take you up to some seriously strong wind in comfort. In the Cav I had to give up and try the next trick at around 60kn. You could sail around the world three times and never see that.

When you can’t keep the boatspeed off even with that rig it is time to do the next thing. At this point you can turn and run, I would use bare poles and a drogue. This has the advantage of also being my choice of “ultimate survival technique”.

If you really don’t want to go the wrong way, either coz you’re a blockhead or you don’t have sea room a sea anchor might be a better bet. Unfortunately most cruisers don’t have the capacity for both. I choose a drogue. I know others who choose a sea anchor. I have always found the drogue painless to set and retrieve which swings it for me.

I like the Jordan series drogue. The idea is to keep a bit of way on (my best guess about 60% of your theoretical hull speed. This means you can steer a very little bit. But more importantly you take the sting out of the waves. I have never been rolled, broached or pooped while using a drogue. I have been in conditions where we were regularly surfing at

 

insane speeds (bare poles on a P38) and broaching at the bottom of the waves. After streaming the drogue that just plain stopped. We were able to clean up, have some food and get into our bunks.

So when I joke about climbing into my bunk and putting a pillow over my head it isn’t really a joke. Keep yourself warm, dry, rested and fed. You and your crew are the boats greatest resource so you need to look after yourself.

Don’t be in a hurry to get somewhere.

Study navigation properly (the instructions for your chart plotter don’t count)

Practice heaving to, learn the joy of simply stopping.

One of my favourite stories is of a couple who took 29 days to do a 1,000 mile passage. I asked what took so long. They said they would always heave to at night and sleep, then get up in the morning and decide whether or not to continue sailing, which they did about every second day.

Or the delivery skipper who was presumed dead when 30 days overdue from Gibraltar to the UK. When he eventually turned up he explained that he was disappointed with the boats leaky decks so he hove to after three days and spent 20 days re caulking the deck. Then continued in a dry boat.

Attitude helps.

  • Upvote 9
Link to post
Share on other sites

Good post BP, and I agree with all of it :-) 

My boat too, wont stay hove too after say over 55-60 knots.  I've no issue with a drogue, esp a jordan series drogue, but my preference is the parachute at this point, esp if the blow is prolonged, or really serious (say 70,80,90Knots).

Ive never been "on the ceiling" worst ive had is a knockdown, never capsized (in a keel boat).

A drogue is lighter and smaller than a parachute, and easier to carry....

Link to post
Share on other sites

Upwind your tactics will be different to downwind. Somewhere around 30kn I stop sailing upwind and heave to.

Are you sure this bit is correct BP? I thought cruisers didn't sail upwind, and specifically, that you have quoted around here somewhere that you haven't sailed upwind in 20 yrs (or words to that effect)  ;-)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Excellent post, thanks BP.  I don't have a drogue, and currently I don't plan to be anywhere near 50+kt winds, but when we do set off away from the coastal weather forecasts in a few years' time I intend to pick up a Jordan for exactly what you describe.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Fish. Upwind to be avoided whenever possible. But heaving to is a valid option to avoid sailing to windward.

 

Kevin. I came up with that 60% based on how the boat was reacting. I really like being able to adjust the drag to get the best ride. I would lead the the legs of the bridle to the primaries via snatch blocks on the quarter for easy adjustment.

Link to post
Share on other sites

We very successfully hove to( or close to it ) in a 46 ft Davidson fin keeler in about 2011. I think 50 knots would be fair  but as David says  its not the wind  , its the monster waves. 

 A real heave to is when you make a slick to windward, I think we might have been technically fore reaching making about 1. 5 knots IIRC, but either way, functionally it was really nice. When it settled the next day we'd spent about 16 or 18 hours in a patch of water about 20 miles square with one 'tack'.

 

The issue ( in retrospect) was we'd sailed onto the Colville ridge , 70 miles off the Kermadecs, where the bottom had gone from  kilometres deep to about 500 odd, 300 odd metres. That ridge turned the sea state into near vertical monsters that defied measurement.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Good read BP

Can’t fault any of it

We hove to in the 2012 RNZ for a watch (3hrs) when the weather bomb was approaching, we had been doing 3 hour watches for 3 days two up and got a good sleep, then we were up to sailing through the worst of the bad stuff.

Tiredness is probably even more dangerous than a calendar

  • Upvote 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

IT I think you need a gems column where post like BP’s can be kept as a resource for all to read again

There is some dribble on this site like all, but sometimes a gold nugget like this appears and need to be put aside as a reference

Just my humble opinion

Link to post
Share on other sites

Navigation today is a tricky one as I am not fully aware of What is being taught if you sign up for a course these days.

What is in my mind is a kind of situational awareness. How does the information you are receiving relate to the real world? How accurate is it? What is a reasonable course based on these considerations.

With a sextant we learned to put a "circle of uncertainty " around a fix. It might be 10 miles or more depending on conditions etc. You would then lay off a course that avoided everything harder than water by 15 miles.

We also learned there is no advantage entering a port (especially one you haven't seen before) in darkness. None whatsoever.

You can heave to and sleep and go in with daylight. Chances are customs will charge you more before 9 am so have breakfast first.

 

I hear people tell me things they have done relying on instruments and it sends a shiver down my spine.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree BP, too an extent. The basic rule of navigation I use is always to have 3 data sources. One can be the mk1 eyeball. Does what you see agree with the plotter, the depth finder, the bearings to obvious features.

Way more yachts are lost due to poor pilotage than offshore.

Can/do you take bearings to check the plotter position

Can you work your tides?

Do you know the rule of 12ths for areas without tidal data?

I have no issue with relying in instruments, provided you check their accuracy.

Old navigation systems (sextant, paper charts etc) can also be wrong, and people make mistakes.

Don't cut corners, be safe out there...

Link to post
Share on other sites

You can rely on them . It's what decisions do you make based on the data they give you.

 

Would you attempt a 100m entrance in zero visibility with gps? Gps plus radar? But what do you gain by doing so and what do you risk? Whats wrong with heaving to till dawn anyway?

 

These are human decisions that too many get wrong.

Link to post
Share on other sites

 You'd never do a tricky pass in first time at night ,...But we left an island in the dark in the Lau last year.  2 boats , we waypointed the hazards on our way in and ran tracks.

 Between the 2 boats I think we were running  6 different chart systems including Google earth. 3 miles across the lagoon and then a pass.

 The reason you do it as you know is you need to time your arrival at your destination and because it was 70 miles  we had to leave early. We had intended to do a new pass ( to us ) into Vanua balavu so that drove the timing, that had to be in daylight. We didn't have problem with it  and had plenty of information . Plus it was fairly windy so we had slop breaking on the pass entrance / edges as great confirmation  that we were bang on track..

Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree, tiredness is a problem, especially with decision making when it gets tough and if you are the skipper the pressure is on to make a call.  Keep rested and try and sleep, easier said than done sometimes when it's rough.  

 

In some ways these days we have so much information especially weather you are more inclined not to make a decision.  Often you have 3-4 weather models and making the right call means sometimes waiting.  In the old weatherfax days you only had a rough idea.  

 

Also when the weather turns nasty for me I sometimes push to get somewhere harder than I should.  You just want to get somewhere else, and probably the more prudent thing to do is to ease the sheets reef and take a rest.  

Link to post
Share on other sites

You can rely on them . It's what decisions do you make based on the data they give you.

 

Would you attempt a 100m entrance in zero visibility with gps? Gps plus radar? But what do you gain by doing so and what do you risk? Whats wrong with heaving to till dawn anyway?

 

These are human decisions that too many get wrong.

Just GPS that's one source, GPS and Radar, better, but that's 2 sources. It's night, so eyeball is no good in an unlit entry.

 

GPS and Radar agree, and fwd scanning sonar all agree with chart? I'd still be reluctant 1st time through there at night. Might try it in calm conditions, if any of those things disagreed at all, no way.

Link to post
Share on other sites

experiment... shows for me ,Photobucket is working again ( for how long I don't know). I always liked this photo taken when we were hove to off the Kermadecs on my mates 46 ft Davidson.

Usually windy days and high sea states don't really show up that way in photos, but this kind of captures the feel eh.

 

IMG_9634_14.jpg

  • Upvote 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...