A quick comment from an alternate universe:
ML King taught us that, if we determine that a law is unjust,
we can and should break it; but we should also be prepared to
accept the legal consequences (without whining).
That way, we can show our respect for the law in general while breaking a particular law.
Kind of like Socrates' approach.
On the whole, I support Mr. Smith.
Who knows, he might be able to strike a blow for the freedom of the seas by his action.